A Matinee Mixed Bag

As the Tigers’ slide (and the Indians’ surge) gathered velocity over the past week or so, I realized how it pushed me farther away from the baseball/information complex.

I’ve stopped watching Baseball Tonight, skipped over the Baseball Today podcast each morning, and avoided the various Power Rankings. It ain’t been easy.

Rogers’ Roost

Even though the Tigers, mathematically at least, remain in the Wild Card hunt, I’m having a hard time letting them back in. It’s like the high school girlfriend that calls shortly after breaking up with you. You’re hoping she wants to reconcile but all she wants to know is when she should drop off your jacket.

Complicating matters for Tigers fans is the performance by Kenny Rogers on Wednesday night. Was this a sign of better things to come (presumably in the 2007 season yet) or just the odds playing out? Regardless of how those questions get answered, I’ll say this: No Tigers player has risen in stature for me like Rogers.

What about Gary Sheffield, you ask? Different story. We knew Sheff was Hall of Fame caliber. Rogers was solid in Texas, a washout in pinstripes, and then he became a serviceable, briefly hot-headed vagabond. At best I expected a Frank Tanana clone.

Who expected the lefty to sparkle the way he did in the 2006 postseason? Anyone? The man secured his place in Tigers lore with those three playoff victories.

Clearly the Tigers’ brass knew what he brought to the team when he signed in December 2005.

That’s why they do what they do, and I do this.

Playing Pepper

  • I’m glad to see the Cameron Maybin Experiment come to a close. It became clear that he wasn’t going to help the team — offensively or defensively — this year. With an expanded roster you can afford to keep a 20-year-old pinch runner.
  • The designated hitter can be used for any player in the lineup. Wonder if Jim Leyland has considered DHing Pudge or Brandon Inge.
  • How about Ramon Santiago stinging the ball more often this year? If he could hit .240 he might be the Tigers’ 2008 shortstop.
  • Jeremy “Nuke” Bonderman? It’s becoming more apparent that Bondo is closer in makeup to Ebby Calvin “Nuke” Laloosh of Bull Durham fame (i.e., million-dollar arm, five-cent head) than to the second coming of Jack Morris. I said it in the offseason and I’ll say it again: the Tigers should have dealt Bonderman this past winter when his value was high.
  • Even before the White Sox began to tank, I looked ahead at the last weekend of the season and saw them on the Tigers schedule. If Detroit’s Wild Card hopes depend on a strong finish at U.S. Cellular Field, I’m afraid we won’t be watching the Tigers play in October.

Finally, I mentioned to Ian Casselberry in an instant message that the contrived nickname thing in sports has gotten out of hand. Need proof? The nickname for former Tigers catcher and current Diamondbacks skipper Bob Melvin: BoMel.

Ian called it the worst first name/last name combo he’s ever seen.


Published by

Mike McClary

Upbeat guy.

2 thoughts on “A Matinee Mixed Bag”

  1. There is no reason for the Tigers to trade Jeremy Bonderman, and any call to trade him over the offseason was foolish and short-sighted. He is YOUNG, and even though he is experienced, he cannot be counted on to disclose his first major injury. Who would they have traded him for? Another young pitcher with equal talent, yeah right. Another man in the lineup that we don’t need? If you in fact did argue for a Bonderman trade, I cannot possibly imagine your justification.


  2. John,

    Good point on the youth thing and Bonderman’s being hesitant to disclose his elbow problems. Clearly he wanted to show his toughness and battle through it.

    Now, my rationale for dealing him: If the Tigers showed an organizational weakness last year it was at first base and outfield depth. I thought Bonderman’s value was at its highest last winter and wouldn’t have been surprised to see the Tigers parlay him and a prospect into a Mark Teixeira-level first baseman and a shortstop or outfielder. These are positions at which the Tigers have displayed virtually zero prospects. I guessed that the Tigers brass would look at the farm system and decide Bondo could go and be replaced by the talent in the bushes.

    I’m wondering how long the “he’s still young” argument will play when he’s in his sixth major league season in 2008.

    I hope I’m wrong and that he matures, develops a change up and is the staff ace Tigers fans expect him to be for the next decade.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s