This post will not please the mouth-breathing, knuckle-scraping, Sports Radio-calling, Dombrowski haters. But it is the truth. Dave Dombrowski is the best GM in baseball, and he just proved it again. For the third year in a row (and in a lousy market for contenders needing to shore up a position or two), DD went out and made a move that no one saw coming to address his team’s needs.
First he got a much-needed veteran back-of-the-bullpen arm in Houston’s closer Jose Veras for a 19-year-old OF prospect. Veras gives Jim Leyland plenty of depth and options for the late innings, and lessens the chance that he’ll have to rely on someone he doesn’t trust (Coke, Alburquerque, Valverde, etc.).
Then, in the closest thing to a blockbuster that this year’s trading deadline produced, he solved shortstop for this year and for the next few years. Jose Iglasias is universally regarded as the second coming of Omar Vizquel and Ozzie Smith defensively (and if he hits like them, that would be pretty good too). He is only 23 years old, and he can play all over the infield. Right now, that’s pretty important, what with Miggy’s hip/ab issues, Infante’s anke, and Peralta’s impending PED suspension. When the other shoe drops for Jhonny, Iglasias will slide into SS, and immediately improve the left side of the infield, because Miggy won’t have to cover as much ground. While Peralta is here (most likely through the weekend) Iglasias provides the luxury of resting Cabrera against a team that they shouldn’t need his help to beat.
Now, Iglasias didn’t come free. But hey, nothing worth anything does. But Dombrowski got him without giving up the jewel of the farm system, Nick Castellanos, who now moves to the front of the line for a call-up when injuries or ineffectiveness strike the major league roster. It will hurt to see Avisail Garcia in a White Sox uniform for the next few years, but seeing Iglasias scoop up everything hit near him for that same amount of time will ease the pain. Garcia was projected to be a very good ML outfielder, maybe even an All-Star. But the Tigers had a surplus at OF in the minors AND the majors, and a dearth of sure-fire middle infield prospects, and nobody that was close to being ready to step in now or next year at SS.
Once again, Dombrowski never tipped his hand, and the deal he eventually made caught everyone by surprise, and solved the exact weakness of the roster as it stood. In 2011, it was Fister, last year Sanchez and Infante, and now, Veras and Iglasias. Each time, he gave up highly-touted prospects to get exactly what he needed. So far, the young players haven’t come back to haunt him or the Tigers. Garcia, and Jacob Turner may yet do that. But even if they do, Dombrowski and the Tigers are still WAY on the positive side of the ledger when it comes to trades. Just ask the Marlins.